17 Comments

  1. JohnGrant213

    Hmm i kind of wonder why Hill has never previously mentioned this information in his other books. It seems like these events could of been how things actually went down although information from Hill well has to kind of be taken with some skepticism at times. I actually look forward to reading this one and seeing how much it differs from what we previously thought was how things went down.

    • The mafia

      This is the biggest laid of rubbish if this was true he would of mentioned it before its funny how henry in his first book before castanlano was whacked did not mention John gotti but after paul got whacked the more and more he mentions John gotti he talks so much bullshit henry hill was a nobody as was most of the guys around him including desimone only reason anyone cares is because of the goodfellas

  2. bellomo boss

    Please this is hogwash. Henry was a drunk and pathological liar. Gotti had just been released from prison and was a captain. No way he would meet with junkie like hill. Plus he had a crew, he would not commit murder, most likely it would have been passed to ruggerio or gene. This a bad attempt to sell a book. Henry has changed his story hundreds of times to get attention and money for booze. Burke killed Desimone because he was a loose cannon

    • JohnGrant213

      I really lean to this as well and its i guess not out of the realm of possibility that Gotti would of whacked the guy himself as he was quite the hot head as well although it does seem a bit unlikely. As i mentioned i am also a little weary and skeptical of some of the things Hill has said in the past. I am a tad interested as to how far some of this “info” is stretched and added and if anyone comes along to somehow corroborate any of it.

    • The mafia

      I don’t believe anything hill says he never mentioned this before and he never used to talk about John gotti in his first book he does not even mentions John gotti this was before paul got whacked after paul goes he talks more and more about John henry prob never even met the guy if this was true John would of been indicted the feds had a major hardon for John in the late 80s early 90s they would have indicted him with anything if this was true we would of heard about it then not 35 years later its rubbish henry was always lowlife thug a junkie no one cared about

  3. StoneToTheBone

    According to FBI informant Joseph “Joe Dogs” Iannuzzi he claimed that Gambino crime family soldier Thomas “Tommy A” Agro confessed to him that he killed Thomas DeSimone and his brother Anthony DeSimone. Joe Dogs was part of Agro’s crew even though Agro was just a soldier at the time.

  4. bellomo boss

    Lots of people wanted tommy dead, but it was not Gotti. People use his name because he was so well known, it helps sell books. I bet it was Burke and vario who set it up. They knew he was a loose cannon and he knew too much about the heist and subsequent murders. Plus heat from gambinos for unsanctued hits. Actual shooter? Who knows. My money is on Burke, Anthony center or someone from demeo crew.

    • Sharp S.

      The heat from the Gambino’s and perhaps some from Gotti def seems to have influenced the decision to have him clipped but to believe that Gotti himself showed up to pull the trigger , welllll that just seems like a very very big stretch.

  5. Dom Woods

    This is the biggest load of shite ever , if this was remotely true do u not think Nick pileggi would have stated this years and years ago ?? Gotti as far as I know was inly involved personally in 3 killings , the mcbratney murder were he never pulled the trigger , Ralph galione did and the murders of vito borelli and Anthony plate as a favour to Neil dellacroce who was on trial with plate in Florida , it’s doubtful he pulled the trigger in the latter two aswel , those were prob willy boy Johnson and ange ruggiero

    • Sharp S.

      Right Dom it seems if Gotti was the trigger man here esp in a room with other mobsters we would of heard this somewhere down the line by now. With all rats that have come forward since and the way many mob guys these days like to shoot the bull with these kinds of stories would think it surfaces somewhere else along the way. I guess in the end we will never know for sure but just seems like a long shot.

  6. eddiea

    Don’t know what to believe about Tommys death,but since Hill knew he was dying this might be the truth. Ppl always try to clear their conciences before they die,especially if they haven’t led good lives.

  7. Michael Robinson

    John was not the trigger man that killed desimone it was a guy named mickey debatt who was the trigger man who was later killed himself by another associate of the Gambino family. Back in those days being a kid knowing these guys and watching them do their thing was fascinating but as an adult looking back they were all.a bunch of shitheads that were all in it for themselfs. One good.guy i remember althought he was crazy he was a.good hearted neighborhood guy was sammy i know he was a rat and a killer as well but as a kid growing up with him around he was the.most generous as long as I remember

  8. Tony Messino

    I know where Tommy DeSimone is buried. The persons basement where the body is was an associate of the Gambino family. This associate is now dead from natural causes. He sold the property 2 years before his death but the body is still in the basement. I know this because I was friends with the associates brother and the brother showed me the burial area in his basement.

Leave a Reply