Joey Merlino the alleged boss of the Philadelphia mafia sat in a courtroom in New York on Thursday while prosecutors attempted to use his own words against him.
During his second day of testimony, J.R. Rubeo spent most of his time guiding the jury through about two dozen audio and videotapes he secretly recorded. Prosecutors are using this key evidence in the case to document Skinny Joey’s role in a multi-million dollar healthcare scam and gambling activities. These charges stem from his alleged role as a leader in what the feds have labeled as the East Coast LCN Enterprise. They claim Merlino along with alleged Genovese crime family capos Pasquale “Patsy” Parrello and Eugene “Rooster” O’Nofrio were on control of the Cosa Nostra based organization that operated up and down the East Coast.
“J.R. Rubeo and Joseph Merlino”
One of the secret recordings captured Merlino telling O’Nofrio and Rubeo “Listen, it’s easy to kill somebody. It’s simple get in the car and shoot you in the f—ing head and you’re dead.” But the defense is expected to counter and play a statement made by Merlino following those comments in which he said “It’s better when you save a friend. I would never put nobody in harm’s way. And we’re all friends here.” The comments are from a conversation the trio was having at a sit-down in a restaurant back in February of 2014. They also talked about family and whether or not a certain mobster was protected while having drinks.
On a separate recording, O’Nofrio confronted Rubeo about a missed interest payment by his brother-in-law on a $30 grand mafia loan. O’Nofrio tells Rubeo “What do I got to do with him? Do you have to take his eyes out? … I don’t want you to get upset because he’s your brother-in-law. I don’t know what the f— he thinks he is. Who does he think he’s f—ing with? Straighten it out. I want my six ($600) Monday.” Prosecutors then introduced photos of O’Nofrio and Merlino together outside of a restaurant during a Christmas party in the Bronx in 2014. They didn’t know it at the time but it was the FBI that was hosting the event for the 20 or so reputed mobsters. The feds forked over $25 grand to fund the event and Rubeo testified that the attendees were “basically all the organized crime figures I was associated with.” Prosecutors played another recorded conversation where Merlino can be heard telling a bookmaker “you gotta give me something every month.” Merlino is heard saying “We’re Gangsters” in another of the conversations.
Rubeo also explained to the jury how he, Merlino, and others split $600 per prescription in the compound pain cream scheme they ran. He said “It was a scam. They weren’t in pain, they came cause we paid them” according to a report by investigative reporter Dave Schratwieser. In a conversation between the two Merlino can be heard saying he is dead broke and “I wanna get paid.” But Merlino’s lawyers claim that he had no idea the compound pain cream operation he was involved in was illegal. Joey’s defense attorney Edwin Jacobs is sure to attack Rubeo’s credibility during cross-examination along with addressing certain missteps by both Rubeo and the feds while he was working as an informant.
Dave was able to catch up to Merlino heading into the courtroom on Thursday. When asked about Rubeo and his testimony Merlino said he couldn’t say anything but Joey still sounded upbeat when asked what he thought about the case saying “We got a good shot.” He even had a last word on the upcoming Superbowl saying “The game on Sunday. Eagles. Win outright.” The Joey Merlino trial continues on Friday!


Def doesn’t seem like it was all that great a day for joey. Some of the stuff on those tapes sound bad to a jury and its the kind of stuff that seems hard to distract them from so Jacobs def has his work cut out for him. Hard to know how convincing Rubeo has been to the jury but if Jacobs can’t break him down it may not matter the tapes alone may get at least a partial conviction and put Joey back behind bars.
Not been the best day for him however trial just started jacobs has not started cross examining rubeo yet. Going to be interesting will get a better idea where this is going in a few days.
Unrelated to merlino but what is O’Nofrio thinking taking this to trial hes fucked with those tapes if he gets convicted in court he will get 20 years then again probably offered him a heavy plea and he is an old man might not be worth it for him
I was thinking the same thing not sure what he was thinking not taking a plea deal if it was anything remotely reasonable. These tapes are def gonna be hard for him to get away from.
Fuck those tapes!!Bits and pieces of a much larger conversation takin out of context and put together by people who need a job!!!Lyinass rat fed paid informant witnesses !!My name is John Rubeo and im an admitted gangster !!You aint no gangster !!I didnt wanna go to jail poor me boo hoo!!!So u get up there and lie to save youre own ass??That man didnt break the law u know it and the people know it !!THATS WHY HES GONNA WALK OUT OF COURT!!!IM JOHN RUBEO I SOLD DRUGS !!!U SOLD LIES IS WHAT U SOLD U SOLD YOURE SOUL FOR YOURE FREEDOM!ITSS NOT THIS LIFE THAT WE HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT ITS THE NEXT!!
I dont care what anybody says about me ..call me crazy …but GREATER LOVE HATH NO MAN THAN HE LAY DOWN HIS LIFE FOR HIS FRIENDS!!
Not guilty!!!Hes gonna win!!Hes gonna walk!!
The right mental attitude toward any divine promise of God will surely bring it to pass!!!Quote William Marrion Branham …Im claiming victiry for the man!!!
Victory!!!!
Tired of of hearing about this Joseph Merlino character. He’s another John Gotti. Nothing more pathetic to me than a celebrity wannabe attention seeking mobster. Mob bosses are supposed to be like phantoms, like Bernardo Provenzano or Vincent Gigante. It’s an American disease where everyone, mobsters included, wants to be celebrities and be competitive in the rat race of a f*****g popularity contest.